The Surprising Role of User Behavior Signals in Local SEO Rankings
We talk a lot about getting great reviews and making your Google Business Profile super strong. Those are like gold medals for your business! But today, I want to share a fascinating secret: how what customers do after they find you online plays a huge role in how high your business shows up on Google. This is all about The Surprising Role of User Behavior Signals in Local SEO Rankings.
Imagine Google as a very smart detective. It’s always watching, trying to figure out which businesses are truly the best and most helpful for people. It doesn’t just look at what you say about your business. It also looks at what people do when they find you. These actions are called “user behavior signals,” and they’re like secret handshakes that tell Google, “Hey, this business is awesome!”
Most people focus on keywords or getting lots of reviews. And yes, those are important! But these “behavior signals” are like a hidden layer of magic that can really push you to the top. Let’s dig in!
What Are These “Secret Handshakes” or User Behavior Signals?
Think about what a person does when they use Google to find a business. They type something in, they see a list of businesses, and then they pick one. What they do next is what we’re talking about!
Google cares about how people act because it wants to show the best results. If lots of people click on your business and then seem happy with what they find, Google thinks, “Aha! This must be a good match!” If people click on your business and then quickly leave, Google might think, “Hmm, maybe that wasn’t such a great match after all.”
Here are the main secret handshakes Google is watching:
1. Click-Through Rate (CTR): Did They Pick YOU? 👆
Imagine you search for “best coffee shop Camp Hill.” Google shows you a list of 3-5 coffee shops. If 100 people see your business name on that list, and 20 of them click on your business, your Click-Through Rate is 20%.
- Why it helps Local SEO: A high CTR tells Google that your business listing (your name, description, and review stars) is very attractive and relevant to what people are searching for. It’s like winning a popularity contest right on the search results page! Google sees this and thinks, “Lots of people like clicking on this one, so it must be good! Let’s show it more often.”
- A Not-So-Common Stat: While a top Google result usually captures about 27.6% of all clicks (Source: Digital Silk, 2025), a less talked about stat is that jumping from the #2 spot to the #1 spot on Google can lead to a 74.5% increase in your CTR (Source: Digital Silk, 2025). This shows how much more attention the very top spot gets, and your CTR helps you get there! Your name and description on your Google Business Profile, and even your website’s meta description, are super important for this. They need to make people want to click!
2. Dwell Time: Did They Stay Awhile? ⏱️
Once someone clicks on your business from Google (either your website or your Google Business Profile), how long do they stick around? Dwell time is how long someone spends on your page or profile before going back to Google’s search results.
- Why it helps Local SEO: If someone clicks on your local coffee shop’s website and spends 3-5 minutes looking at your menu, reading your story, or checking out your photos, that’s a long dwell time. It tells Google, “This person found exactly what they were looking for! The content is helpful and interesting.” If they click and leave after 5 seconds, that’s a short dwell time, which signals to Google that your page wasn’t a good fit for their search.
- A Not-So-Common Stat: Google’s own leaked documents hint at the importance of “long clicks” (meaning users staying on a page for a good while). While Google doesn’t give a specific number, many SEO experts believe embedding videos on your page can significantly boost dwell time, sometimes by over 200% (Source: Wistia, via Backlinko). This means if you have a video tour of your business or a ‘how-to’ video related to your service, people will stay longer, sending a great signal to Google! (Good thing we specialize in Video Marketing, right?)
3. Bounce Rate: Did They Run Away? 🏃♀️
This is a bit similar to dwell time, but it’s specifically about people who click on your link from Google, visit only one page on your website, and then leave your site completely (often by hitting the back button) without clicking on anything else.
- Why it helps Local SEO (or hurts!): A high bounce rate (lots of people leaving quickly after just one page) can signal to Google that your content wasn’t what the user expected, or it wasn’t helpful. It’s like walking into a store, realizing it’s not what you wanted, and walking right back out. Google might think, “Hmm, maybe this business isn’t a great match for that search.”
- A Not-So-Common Stat: While Google doesn’t directly say bounce rate is a ranking factor, research often shows a correlation between low bounce rates and higher Google rankings (Source: Backlinko). What’s less talked about is why people bounce quickly. It’s often because your page isn’t easy to read, loads too slowly, or doesn’t match what the searcher expected. For example, if someone searches for “Camp Hill bakery hours” and your page shows a long history lesson without the hours easily visible, they’ll bounce! Ensuring your website is fast and mobile-friendly also reduces bounces.
4. Return to SERP (Search Engine Results Page): Did They Go Back to Google? ↩️
This is a really important one. If someone clicks on your business listing, goes to your website or Google Business Profile, but then quickly clicks the “back” button to go back to Google’s search results to pick a different business – that’s a negative signal. Google sees this as a “pogo-sticking” behavior, meaning your result wasn’t satisfying.
- Why it helps Local SEO (or hurts!): If many people click on your listing and then immediately return to the search results to choose a competitor, Google figures your business wasn’t the best answer to that search. It might then push your listing lower for similar searches.
- A Not-So-Common Stat: It’s hard to get exact numbers from Google on “return to SERP,” but it’s strongly related to user satisfaction. What’s often overlooked is that this signal becomes even more powerful when Google’s own features (like your Google Business Profile) provide the answer directly. For instance, if someone searches ‘Camp Hill auto repair phone number’ and finds your number right in the Google Business Profile knowledge panel without having to click your website, that’s a positive direct interaction signal. Google wants to provide instant answers.
What Does This Mean for Your Small Business?
These user behavior signals are like Google’s secret sauce for understanding true popularity and relevance. It’s not enough just to appear on Google; you need to make sure that once people find you, they like what they see and stay engaged.
Here’s how you can make sure your business sends strong, positive behavior signals:
- Optimize Your Google Business Profile Like a Pro: This is your virtual storefront! Make sure your business name, address, phone number (NAP), hours, photos, and services are perfect and enticing. A complete profile encourages clicks and direct calls/directions (which are strong user signals). Our Google Business Optimization Program (https://businesssolutionsmarketinggroup.com/google-business-optimization-pro/) is built exactly for this, ensuring your profile is a magnet for engagement.
- Make Your Website Amazing: Is it easy to use? Does it load super fast? (A slow site is a huge bounce rate problem!) Is the information clear and easy to find? Is it mobile-friendly? More than half of all website traffic comes from organic search, so your website experience is critical (Source: Digital Silk, 2025).
- Create Engaging Content: Don’t just list services. Tell your story! Use videos (we love video marketing!), high-quality photos, and write in a friendly way. This keeps people on your page longer, boosting dwell time.
- Manage Your Reputation (and Reviews!): Positive reviews encourage clicks (higher CTR!) and a strong overall rating makes people more likely to stay engaged. Our Reputation Management and Review Removal services are key here!
- Answer Questions: If people ask questions on your Google Business Profile (remember our last chat?), answer them promptly! This shows engagement and directly helps provide information, reducing bounces.
These user behavior signals are a subtle but incredibly powerful part of local SEO. By focusing on giving your customers the best possible experience after they find you online, you’re not just making them happy – you’re also telling Google that your business deserves to be at the very top of the search results! Don’t underestimate these secret handshakes; they could be your ticket to dominating local search.
GBP LInk – https://g.co/kgs/GR8yH4a
LinkedIn – https://www.linkedin.com/company/business-solutions-marketing-group-llc/?viewAsMember=true
Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/business_solutions_mg/
Twitter – https://x.com/BSMGLLC
Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/BusinessSolutionsMarketingGroup
BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/bussolutions.bsky.social
TikTok – https://www.tiktok.com/@linda_donnelly
YouTube – https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4w357-txvxOaHff2hTfSSg
