Google’s Latest Updates: How They Just Changed the Local SEO Game (Again!)

We’ve seen a lot of changes in how Google works, but lately, things have been particularly… interesting.

If you’ve peeked at your local ranking reports or heat map audits lately and thought, “Huh, that’s weird, my service area seems to have shrunk,” you are absolutely not alone. My phone has been buzzing with similar questions from clients, and we’ve been tracking this trend closely. Over the past few weeks, we’ve seen a noticeable dip in local rankings across the board, and it’s not just a few businesses; it’s happening globally. Businesses that used to rank well in a nice, wide service area are now finding their visibility shrinking back closer to their actual physical locations.

Combine that with lower engagement metrics like views and clicks, partly due to how many people are now using Google’s AI Mode for instant answers, and yeah, it’s a bit of a head-scratcher. It feels like Google is getting pickier, and the algorithm is evolving faster than ever. But don’t panic – just stay consistent with your optimizations, because now more than ever, they help you on Google Search, Google Maps, and in AI Mode.

Today, I want to break down these recent shifts in Google ranking and local SEO, explain what they mean for your business, and share what we’re doing to help our clients stay ahead.

The Shrinking Service Area: Why Your Local Ranking Might Look “Weird”

Let’s talk about this “shrinking service area” phenomenon first, because it’s probably the most noticeable change for local businesses. For years, if you had a strong Google Business Profile (GBP) and good SEO, you could often rank for searches happening a good distance from your physical address. Now, it seems Google is tightening the reins.

Proximity is King (Again, but Stronger): It appears Google is putting an even heavier emphasis on proximity – how close your business is to the person doing the searching. If someone searches “plumber near me” or “dentist Grand Rapids,” Google is increasingly prioritizing businesses that are physically closest, even if another business a bit further away might have slightly better reviews or more website content. This is a subtle but significant shift in Google ranking.
The “Why”: Google’s Refinement: Why is Google doing this? My best guess, based on years of observing their patterns, is that they’re trying to deliver the most relevant and convenient results possible. For many local services, the closest option truly is the most convenient. Their algorithm is getting more refined, trying to understand user intent with pinpoint accuracy.
Impact of AI Mode on Clicks: We’re also seeing lower engagement metrics like views and clicks on traditional search results. This is partly due to the rise of AI Mode (now expanded to Google Workspace accounts, meaning nearly everyone is using it!). When people get instant answers directly on the Google search page – through Featured Snippets, People Also Ask boxes, or AI Overviews – they don’t always need to click through to a website. As of May 2025, a whopping 69% of Google searches are “zero-click” searches. (Source: Similarweb, May 2025 data). This means fewer clicks for everyone, regardless of how high you rank.

So, if your local ranking seems to have pulled back, don’t panic. It’s not necessarily something you did wrong. It’s Google evolving.

A Glimmer of Hope: Google’s Improved Suspension Appeals

Now, for some genuinely good news! While the algorithm changes can be frustrating, Google just rolled out a very welcome improvement to its suspension appeal process. This is a massive step in the right direction, especially since a Google Business Profile suspension can be a business-killer.

The Old Nightmare: In the past, if your GBP was suspended and your appeal was denied, Google wouldn’t tell you why. You were left completely in the dark, playing “GBP detective” trying to figure out what triggered the suspension. It was incredibly frustrating and often led to endless guessing games and wasted effort.
The New Clarity: Now, if your appeal gets denied, Google tells you exactly why. This is huge! It means you’re no longer left guessing. You get clear feedback on what policy was violated or what information was incorrect. This allows you to fix the specific problem and resubmit a more informed appeal. Google started doing this with failed verifications last year, and they’re finally applying that logic to suspensions too. This kind of transparency helps businesses immensely.

This improvement shows that while Google is making its ranking rules tighter, they are also trying to be more helpful when businesses run into trouble.

Adapting to Google’s Evolution: Doubling Down on Fundamentals

At the end of the day, it’s clear that Google’s algorithm is evolving and becoming more refined in how it ranks and displays local businesses. We’re seeing tighter service areas, shifting engagement metrics, and more sensitivity to small changes, which tells us the algorithm is getting pickier.

So, what’s the best move right now for local SEO? It’s to double down on the fundamentals. These core strategies are what Google always values, and they’re what will keep your business visible no matter how the algorithm shifts:

Keep Your Google Business Profile Fully Optimized: This is your digital storefront, and it needs to be perfect.
- Accuracy is Paramount: Ensure your Name, Address, and Phone number (NAP) are 100% consistent everywhere online. 62% of consumers would avoid using a business if they found incorrect information online. (Source: BrightLocal).
- Completeness Builds Trust: Fill out every single section of your GBP: categories, hours, services, photos, and descriptions. Businesses with a complete Google Business Profile are 2.7 times more likely to be seen as reputable by customers. (Source: Google).
- Fresh Visuals: Keep your photos and videos updated. Google loves fresh content, and so do customers. Our Google Business Listing Optimization service is designed to handle all these details for you.
Get Great, Genuine Reviews (and Respond to Them!): Reviews are a massive factor in local ranking and trust.
- Ask for Them: Make it easy for happy customers to leave reviews.
- Respond to All: Whether good or bad, respond professionally. 88% of consumers are likely to use a business if they see the owner respond to all reviews. (Source: Loopex Digital, 2025). This builds immense trust.
- Quality Over Quantity (But Both Help): Detailed, specific reviews are more valuable than generic ones. Our Reputation Management services and Review Removal service are here to help you manage and protect your online reputation.
Stay Active and Engaged: A stagnant GBP sends a bad signal.
- Google Posts: Use them regularly to share updates, specials, or news.
- Q&A Section: Monitor and answer questions in your GBP’s Q&A section. This shows engagement and provides helpful info.
- Website Freshness: Keep your website content updated and relevant to your local audience.

Here’s a less common stat: While 44% of local clicks go to the Map Pack, 28% of local searches lead to a purchase. (Source: Google). This highlights the high conversion rate of local searchers – they’re ready to buy! Your job is to be visible and trustworthy.

At the end of the day, it’s clear that Google’s algorithm is always evolving, becoming more refined and sensitive. The recent shifts in Google ranking for local businesses, including tighter service areas and the impact of AI Mode, tell us that quality, accuracy, and consistency are more important than ever. The good news about the suspension appeal process means Google is also trying to be clearer when things go wrong.

As always, my team and I at Business Solutions Marketing Group will keep tracking these changes, running tests, and staying on top of what works. We’ve been doing this for over a decade, helping small businesses like yours adapt and thrive. Don’t let these updates make your business invisible. Reach out to us today for a consultation, and let’s ensure your local SEO strategy is ready for whatever Google throws our way.

External Link for further reading: